For most lists, the cheaper model comes down to one number: how many emails you send per contact each month. Send fewer than roughly 8 to 16 full-list campaigns a month (the exact figure depends on list size) and paying per email is cheaper. Send more than that, especially on a large list, and a flat subscriber tier with unlimited sends usually wins.
Below I work the maths with a verified contact-tier price (MailerLite, as of November 2026) against a send-based rate of £5 plus £0.40 per 1,000 emails, at 5,000, 25,000, 100,000 and 250,000 contacts, and cover the two costs tier pricing hides well: contacts you pay for but never email, and the jump when you cross a tier by one subscriber.
The three email marketing pricing models
1. Contact tiers (subscriber-based pricing)
You pay a flat monthly fee for a band of contacts, such as "up to 10,000 subscribers". Sending is either unlimited or capped at a multiple of your contact count. Mailchimp's Essentials plan allows 10 times your contact limit in monthly sends, Standard 12 times and Premium 15 times, according to its pricing page as of November 2026. MailerLite's Comfort plan is 10 times; its Power plan is unlimited.
The appeal is predictability. The catch is that price tracks list size, not activity, so a dormant list costs the same as a busy one.
2. Send volume (pay per email pricing)
You pay for emails actually sent, usually a small base fee plus a per-thousand rate. List size is irrelevant; you can hold a million contacts and pay nothing until you press send. Cost follows activity, so a heavy schedule on a big list adds up quickly.
3. Credits (pay-as-you-go)
You buy email credits up front, typically at a higher per-thousand rate than a monthly send plan, and spend them whenever you like. Interspire, for instance, sells credits at £0.60 per 1,000 with a £10 minimum, and they never expire. Credits suit seasonal senders who would otherwise pay a monthly fee in months they send nothing.
The break-even formula
Call your list size N, your sends per contact per month f, and the tier price you are comparing against T (in pounds). On the send-based plan used throughout this article:
Send-based cost = £5 + £0.40 × (N × f ÷ 1,000)
Set that equal to T and solve for f:
Break-even sends per month = (T − £5) ÷ (£0.0004 × N)
Send fewer campaigns than that and pay-per-email is cheaper; send more and the tier is cheaper. Two things follow. The break-even point drops as the list grows, because tier prices rise more slowly per contact than per-email cost does. And a tier with a 10× send cap cannot save you money if its break-even is above 10, because you are not allowed to send that often.
Break-even table: MailerLite tiers vs £0.40 per 1,000
Tier prices are MailerLite's monthly-billed USD prices read from the subscriber calculator on mailerlite.com/pricing on 18 November 2026, converted at the European Central Bank reference rate of 1 USD = 0.759 GBP for the same day (source) and rounded to the pound. Comfort allows 10 sends per contact per month; Power is unlimited.
| Contacts | Comfort (10× cap) | Power (unlimited) | Break-even vs Comfort | Break-even vs Power |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 5,000 | $49 (£37) | $69 (£52) | 16 sends/mo (above the cap) | 24 sends/mo |
| 10,000 | $89 (£68) | $129 (£98) | 16 sends/mo (above the cap) | 23 sends/mo |
| 25,000 | $179 (£136) | $239 (£181) | 13 sends/mo (above the cap) | 18 sends/mo |
| 100,000 | $439 (£333) | $489 (£371) | 8 sends/mo | 9 sends/mo |
| 200,000 | $819 (£622) | $1,119 (£850) | 8 sends/mo | 11 sends/mo |
Read it like this. At 25,000 contacts you would need 13 full-list campaigns a month before Comfort became cheaper than paying per email, but Comfort only permits 10, so pay-per-email wins at every frequency that tier allows. At 100,000 contacts the picture flips: anyone sending twice a week or more is better off on a tier. MailerLite moves to custom Enterprise pricing above 200,000 subscribers, so there is no listed price at 250,000; budget from the 200,000 tier.
Reality check: These figures assume you email the whole list every time. Most senders do not. If half your campaigns go to a 30% segment, your effective sends per contact are far below your campaign count, which tilts the break-even further towards paying per email.
Worked examples at 5k, 25k, 100k and 250k contacts
Two sending patterns: a weekly newsletter to the full list (4 sends a month) and a near-daily schedule (20 sends a month). Send-based costs use £5 + £0.40 per 1,000; credit costs use £0.60 per 1,000 with no base fee.
| List size | Weekly: send-based / credits / tier | 20 sends: send-based / tier | Cheaper at weekly | Cheaper at 20 sends |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 5,000 | £13 / £12 / £37 Comfort | £45 / £52 Power | Credits or send-based | Send-based, narrowly |
| 25,000 | £45 / £60 / £136 Comfort | £205 / £181 Power | Send-based | Tier |
| 100,000 | £165 / £240 / £333 Comfort | £805 / £371 Power | Send-based | Tier, by a wide margin |
| 250,000 | £405 / £600 / custom (200k tier £622) | £2,005 / custom (200k Power £850) | Send-based | Tier, by a wide margin |
The pattern is consistent. A weekly newsletter is cheaper on pay-per-email at every size tested, by a factor of two to three. Once you send most days to 25,000 contacts or more, tiers are cheaper, and a daily sender at 100,000 would pay more than twice as much per email. Frequency decides it.
Credits sit in the middle. At 5,000 contacts the £12 credit cost beats the £13 monthly plan because there is no base fee. At 25,000 and above the £0.20 per 1,000 premium outweighs the saved base fee, so a monthly send plan is the better pay-per-email option for regular senders. Our newsletter platform pricing guide runs the same exercise across more vendors.
Zombie contacts and what cleaning does to your bill
A zombie contact is one you keep but never really send to: unengaged for six months or more, excluded from most segments, kept "just in case". On a tier plan they are a direct cost. On a send-based plan they cost nothing until you email them.
Take a 25,000-contact list where 10,000 have not opened anything in six months, a common ratio. On MailerLite Comfort you pay £136 for the 25,000 band. Remove those 10,000 and you drop to the 15,000 band at $129, about £98. The zombies cost £38 a month, £456 a year, whether or not you send them anything. On the send-based plan the same 10,000 contacts cost £16 a month inside four weekly sends, and £0 if you suppress them while keeping the records for compliance.
Cleaning therefore works in opposite ways. On tiers, it saves money only when you cross a band boundary: removing 1,000 dead contacts from 25,000 saves nothing, removing 10,001 saves about £38 a month. The question is not "how many can I remove?" but "how many must I remove to reach the next band down without cutting into people who still read?". On send-based pricing, every suppressed contact saves money on every campaign, immediately and in proportion. The incentive is gentler but continuous, and it rewards what deliverability teams want anyway.
Either way, clean carefully. Our guide on how to clean an email list safely covers tagging rather than deleting and keeping suppression lists intact, and our re-engagement email guide shows how to give dormant contacts one last chance first.
Pro Tip: Before you clean, export a count of contacts by last-engaged date. On a tier plan, if the cleanse will not cross a band, hold the contacts in a suppressed segment and revisit at renewal. On a send-based plan, suppress them today; the saving starts with the next campaign.
How tier cliffs work
Tier pricing is a staircase, not a slope. Within a band your price is flat; cross the upper limit by one contact and you pay the next band's price for all of them. The jump at 10,000 is the one growing lists hit first.
On MailerLite's calculator, 10,000 subscribers prices Comfort at $89 and Power at $129. Enter 10,001 and it snaps to the 15,000 band: Comfort $129, Power $179. That single contact adds $40 a month (about £30) to Comfort, a 45% increase, or $480 a year. Mailchimp uses the same banded structure with its own breakpoints.
- Cost per contact is highest just after a cliff and lowest just before the next one. A 10,001-contact list pays the same as a 15,000-contact list.
- Growth can cost money before it earns it. Adding 500 subscribers the month you sit at 9,800 triggers a price rise the newcomers may take months to justify.
- Vendors count unsubscribed and bounced addresses differently. Check before assuming a cleanse will move you down a band.
Send-based pricing has no cliffs. Going from 100,000 to 100,001 emails costs £0.0004 more, not 45%.
Cases where subscriber tiers are cheaper
This is not a one-sided comparison. Tiers win clearly in three common situations:
- High-frequency senders on large lists. A 100,000-contact list emailed 20 times a month pays £805 send-based against £371 on MailerLite Power. Daily deal sites, publishers and flash-sale retailers belong here.
- Heavy automation and transactional volume. Onboarding, cart recovery, win-back flows and order notices can add several emails per contact per month on top of campaigns, and unlimited sending becomes valuable fast.
- Budget certainty. A fixed tier is easier to forecast, and some finance teams will accept a higher flat fee over a lower variable one. That is a legitimate preference, even if it is not the cheapest arithmetic.
Conversely, pay-per-email wins for weekly or fortnightly newsletters, seasonal senders, large lists with low engagement, and anyone whose list grows faster than their sending. If a switch is on the cards, our guide on how to migrate email platforms covers the practical steps.
Decision checklist: which email pricing model fits your list?
Answer with last quarter's numbers, not aspirations.
- How many full-list campaigns did you send last month? Under 8, pay-per-email is almost certainly cheaper. Over 15, look at tiers.
- What share of contacts opened anything in the last 90 days? Below 50%, you are paying tier fees for a lot of zombies.
- How close are you to the next tier boundary? Sitting at 9,800 or 24,500 contacts means a price rise is imminent.
- How many automation emails go out per contact per month? Add these to your campaign count before using the break-even table.
- Do you send every month? If you skip months, credits that never expire beat both monthly models.
- Does your list grow faster than your sending? Fast-growing, low-frequency lists suffer most under tiers.
- Do you need unlimited sends for transactional volume? If yes, an unlimited tier may beat metering every message.
- Does finance value a fixed monthly figure over a lower average? Weigh predictability against the saving and decide consciously.
If most answers point to pay-per-email, compare two or three send-based vendors on the same basis. Interspire's pricing page publishes the £5 plus £0.40 per 1,000 rate used here, with unlimited contacts on every plan, so the figures transfer directly.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is pay per email pricing always cheaper for small lists?
Nearly always under 10,000 contacts, because tier prices at that size imply a break-even of 16 or more full-list sends a month, above the 10× cap most entry tiers impose. The exception is a very small list on a free plan.
How do I convert my campaign count into sends per contact?
Add up every email delivered last month, including automations, and divide by your contact count. A 20,000-contact list that delivered 60,000 emails has an effective frequency of 3 sends per contact.
Do unsubscribed contacts count towards my tier?
It depends on the vendor. Some count only active subscribers; others count every record including unsubscribed and cleaned addresses. Check the billing documentation and, if it counts everything, archive inactive records before your billing date.
Will cleaning my list always reduce my bill?
On a send-based or credit plan, yes, immediately and in proportion. On a contact tier, only if the cleanse takes you below a band boundary; otherwise the price is unchanged until you cross one.